Article

ProPublica

ProPublica

More Than Numbers: Portraits of U.S. Citizens Detained by Immigration Agents

10 days ago

The post More Than Numbers: Portraits of U.S. Citizens Detained by Immigration Agents appeared first on ProPublica .

The Department of Homeland Security says it’s not detaining Americans.

In written statements, it has said that “allegations that ICE is arresting and deporting U.S. citizens is FALSE.”

It has said that “when individuals are briefly questioned under ‘reasonable suspicion’ and are found to be U.S. citizens, they are immediately released.” And it has said that “U.S. citizen agitators are only held while they actively remain a safety threat to our officers and the public.”

But ProPublica has identified more than 500 citizens detained since President Donald Trump returned to office.

They are not just numbers.

Among them is an elderly car wash owner whom agents repeatedly knocked to the ground as they detained several of his workers. A 6-year-old whose mother says still has nightmares after agents pointed guns at him and his siblings. A high school senior who was detained after she tried to stop officers from questioning her autistic younger brother. A dad who was held for several days and missed his daughter’s third birthday.

Over the past year, several of these people shared the lingering effects of what happened to them with ProPublica.

Ana Michelle Ramirez Sanan

In their own neighborhood
Three people stand close together against a teal wall decorated with sketches and family photos. A young woman in a black shirt stands in the center looking into the camera with her hands clasped in front of her. On the left, an older woman wearing a red shirt and a black wrist brace rests her head on the shoulder of the woman in the center. On the right, a person wearing a black polo shirt leans their head against her other shoulder.
Photographed at their home in a Boston suburb

“We have so much trauma just from the 30 minutes we were held.”

Ana Michelle Ramirez Sanan

In September 2025, Ana Michelle Ramirez Sanan learned that ICE agents had intercepted members of her family as they drove one of her uncles to a court hearing. Ramirez Sanan, then 17, said she rushed to the scene and discovered agents had broken the car windows and pulled her two uncles, her mother and her younger brother out. Video of the incident showed agents kicking and slamming Ramirez Sanan’s mother to the ground and then twisting her arms to handcuff her. Ramirez Sanan said she saw other agents questioning her brother against a fence, threatening to arrest him if he couldn’t prove he had legal status.

Both she and her brother are citizens.

“Him being a 13-year-old with autism, he doesn’t understand these things like we do. He didn’t know what ‘a legal status’ is. He’s not able to tell them: ‘Yes, I have a legal status. I’m born here,’” Ramirez Sanan said. She said that when she rushed toward her mom and brother, begging agents to let them go, they detained her. “It was really scary thinking that they might have taken us and deported us to Guatemala, where we don’t have anything.”

DHS said that its agents intercepted the car in order to detain the uncle who was going to court that day, and that they “used the appropriate force necessary.” He was facing charges of sexual assault on a child and remains in ICE custody. He has pleaded not guilty.

As for Ramirez Sanan, her mother and her brother, they were released the day of the incident. Her mother, who has lived in the United States for 20 years and has a green card, was treated at a hospital for a concussion, bruising and nerve damage in one of her arms.

DHS denies that they were ever detained.

“We have so much trauma just from the 30 minutes we were held,” said Ramirez Sanan, who struggled with anxiety and depression after the incident. “I lost my whole senior year fighting this. My brother isn’t the same either.”

Andrea Velez

On her way to work
A portrait of a woman with long dark hair standing outdoors in a park during golden-hour light. She is wearing an oversized dark denim jacket over a blue patterned sweater and light blue jeans, looking directly toward the camera, against a soft-focus backdrop of green grass and trees.
Photographed in Los Angeles

In June 2025, Andrea Velez was dropped off at work at a shoe company in downtown Los Angeles and inadvertently walked into an immigration raid on street vendors. She said one of the masked agents rushed toward her, grabbed her and slammed her to the pavement. Velez said she attempted to shield herself with her work bag.

“Throughout the whole time, I kept saying I was a U.S. citizen,” Velez recalled, saying that agents called her an “alleged U.S. citizen” even after they checked her ID. “They kept saying how many ‘bodies they got’ that day.”

Velez said that she was detained for two days, and that she was denied an opportunity to call family or a lawyer for most of that time. The government charged Velez with assault. DHS said she “made physical contact” with agents and tried to impede them. A judge ultimately dismissed the case.

After her arrest, Velez said she was so afraid of being detained again that she worked remotely and avoided going outside.

Quentin Williams

At the end of his school day as a teaching assistant
A young man with dreadlocks sits on outdoor concrete steps next to a bright blue handrail. He is dressed in a maroon T-shirt, olive green cargo shorts, white crew socks and black sneakers, looking forward against a backdrop of green grass, leafy trees and a blue fence.
Photographed in Inver Grove Heights, Minnesota

In January, not long after immigration agents in Minneapolis had shot and killed an American woman named Renee Good, Quentin Williams, a teaching assistant at nearby Roosevelt High School, was guiding students toward buses when more agents arrived outside his building.

Williams said that agents began confronting students and staff. At some point during the commotion, he said, the agents threw him to the ground and choked him so hard he couldn’t breathe.

“They didn’t even know what they were doing — just kind of being reckless [with] assault rifles out and pepper-spraying staff after they took me down,” Williams recalled.

Agents drove Williams to the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building, where they detained him for several hours.

Later, then-Attorney General Pam Bondi published his photo on her social media accounts, describing him as a “Minnesota rioter.” Federal authorities issued a warrant for his arrest for assaulting officers. The charges against him were eventually dismissed, and he’s filed a claim against the government for damages over his arrest.

Williams said he’s still haunted by the idea that he came close to meeting the same fates as Good and George Floyd, who was killed by a Minneapolis police officer in 2020. “I didn’t leave the house for at least up to a week,” he said. “I felt lucky to be alive.”

Anabel Romero, John Carter, Juana Rodriguez and their children

Attending a horse race

In October 2025, some 200 federal agents and local police officers in armored vehicles, a helicopter and on horseback conducted a raid on a racetrack in Wilder, Idaho, and detained hundreds of people, including dozens of children. Among them ProPublica identified at least 30 U.S. citizens.

A woman, a teenager and two young children pose together along a paved path in an open park under a clear sky. The children stand in front — a boy in tan sportswear and a girl in a purple shirt — with the woman and teenager standing behind them resting hands on their shoulders.
Photographed at a park in Meridian, Idaho

Anabel Romero had left her kids eating in the car while she went to look at the horses. They were on opposite sides of the track when the raid began.

Romero said the agents wore camouflage and had their guns drawn. She had no idea who they were. So she ran and tried to hide. “They didn’t identify themselves,” Romero said. “I didn’t know who they were.”

She said unidentified officers tackled her, zip-tied her and threatened to “fucking blow your head off.”

On the other side of the track, Romero’s 14-year-old daughter, SueHey Tello, said officers surrounded their car, pointing guns at her brother, 6, and sister, 8. When Tello refused to exit the car without her younger siblings, agents pulled her so roughly out of the car that she fell, leaving bruises. She said agents zip-tied her hands.

Romero and Tello said the agents refused to remove the zip ties for hours, despite Tello’s age. The teenager said the incident has affected her view of law enforcement. Her mother says that the 6-year-old still has nightmares. Officers are meant “to keep us safe,” Tello said. “But yet they treated all of us like that.”

A bearded security guard wearing a black baseball cap that has the word “security” on the front, glasses and a reflective high-visibility vest with the word “security” along the bottom stands outdoors facing the camera with his hands clasped. Flanking him are three other individuals also wearing bright high-visibility vests, facing away toward an open landscape under a clear sky.
Photographed outside of La Catedral Arena in Wilder, Idaho, where they were detained

John Carter was working security at the track when the raid started. He had brought his girlfriend and his two children along with him. He recalls officers throwing a flash-bang near him and his son, and then the officers detained them. “They cinched the zip ties down as tight as they could,” Carter said. He said the officers also zip-tied his 14-year-old daughter but removed the restraints when he complained.

Carter explained that he is active in the local Republican Party and a strong supporter of law enforcement. But he said that what he saw officers doing that day was wrong.

“Things are supposed to be done humanely and correctly,” he said. “This wasn’t.”

A woman with dark hair and glasses sits directly facing the camera on a dark gray couch, hands resting in her lap. She wears a light-colored, floral-patterned pullover jacket and blue jeans against a textured, light gray wall.
Photographed at her home in Caldwell, Idaho

The agents also detained Juana Rodriguez, who attended the event with her family. She said that she was zip-tied beside her 3-year-old son, which left her unable to pick him up and comfort him during the long hours they waited to prove their citizenship. “He wanted me to hug him, to hold him,” Rodriguez said. She and her son are both U.S. citizens and lead plaintiffs in an ACLU of Idaho lawsuit alleging the raid illegally targeted Latinos. ICE, the FBI and several Idaho agencies have denied the charge and asked that the lawsuit be dismissed.

DHS did not respond to any specific allegations made by Rodriguez, Romero, Carter or their families. Instead, a spokesperson wrote in an email statement that the raid successfully helped dismantle an illegal gambling operation, and that ICE officers “didn’t zip tie, restrain or arrest any children.” The FBI declined to comment to ProPublica but told local media no “young children” were zip-tied. DHS, the FBI and multiple Idaho law enforcement agencies have refused to share the number of U.S. citizens held that day.

Amanda Trebach

Monitoring ICE operations
A woman with short brown hair and forearm tattoos stands facing forward in an empty, sunlit paved area wearing an olive green graphic T-shirt and dark pants. In the background, a street leads toward an institutional complex featuring watchtowers, perimeter fencing, utility poles and palm trees under a bright blue sky.
Photographed outside Terminal Island in Los Angeles, where she was detained

“I didn’t want to walk to my apartment by myself; I didn’t want to be out in the dark by myself.”

Amanda Trebach

In August 2025, Amanda Trebach, a nurse and volunteer with an immigrant advocacy organization, said she was monitoring ICE activities outside a facility that the agency was using to stage operations when agents grabbed her and pinned her to the ground, kneeling on her neck and back. They shoved her into the back of a van and held her for several hours until taking her to a federal detention facility in Los Angeles. She was not given the opportunity to speak with an attorney during the 33 hours that she was in custody. She said agents took her phone and never returned it.

DHS said Trebach was detained because she attempted to physically impede its agents’ operations by jumping in front of moving vehicles, hitting their cars with her protest signs and shouting obscenities at agents. She denies this.

She said that after the incident she felt paranoid that she was being followed.

“I didn’t want to walk to my apartment by myself; I didn’t want to be out in the dark by myself,” she said. “I didn’t know if they were going to come get me.”

George Retes

Driving to work
A young man in a white T-shirt and patterned shorts sits in the open driver’s-side door of a white car, looking directly toward the camera in warm evening sunlight. Behind the vehicle, a vast green agricultural field stretches out beneath a pale sky. Read on ProPublica