Article

Axios

Axios

Scoop: The Pentagon's case for Canada to "get serious" on defense

2 hours ago

The Pentagon accused Canada of failing to become a "credible partner" due to its faltering military readiness and low defense spending, according to a sharply worded fact sheet issued by the Pentagon to justify new restrictions on America's northern neighbor. Why it matters: The restrictions deepen tensions between the U.S. and Canada over trade and defense, as Ottawa reconsiders billions of dollars in purchases of American weapons. The new restraints — which do not affect defense or intelligence sharing— limit U.S. military personnel from fraternizing with their Canadian counterparts at official events without prior authorization from the Pentagon, an official told Axios. The Pentagon fact sheet has not been reported. But the Washington Post first reported the restrictions, followed by the New York Times . Zoom in: At the heart of the dispute are NATO defense spending goals and military readiness under the bilateral North American Aerospace Defense Command where, the memo says, Canada falls short in three ways: 🛩️ Air: Only 41.9% of the Royal Canadian Air Force fleet "was serviceable from 2025-2026, largely due to ageing equipment and personnel shortages," the Pentagon fact sheet says. The shortfall limits Canada's "ability to meaningfully contribute to air defense commitments … to defend our North American airspace against all threats." Canada relies on the U.S. and NATO for airborne early-warning aircraft but is negotiating to buy its own from Sweden's Saab. ⚓️ Sea: Just 53.9% of Canada's naval fleet was "serviceable" from 2025-2026, limiting its "ability to monitor maritime approaches to North America," the fact sheet says. Only one of Canada's "four ageing Victoria-class submarines" is "seaworthy at any given time." Canada has a new fleet of conventional submarines, manufactured by ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems, coming on line, but until then, its undersea "capability will be limited." 🪖 Land: The Canadian Army had an operational readiness rate of 48% from 2025-2026. The other side: Canada's own defense department reported the same equipment shortages while finding that 61% of its military units were ready for operations. Canada's defense ministry could not be reached. Friction point : NATO defense spending has been a constant sore spot for President Trump. Canada first agreed to spend 2% of GDP on defense spending in 2006, but it was only at 1.5% until 2025, according to the Pentagon. Canada announced in March that it had achieved 2% GDP-defense spending, but now the target is 5% by 2035 and U.S. policy makers say Ottawa "has yet to articulate a resourced path to reach this target. "Canada must get serious and focused," the fact sheet said. The big picture: More defense spending by NATO allies is a revenue generator for the U.S., which has the globe's largest military-industrial complex. "Since March 2025," the Pentagon fact sheet noted, "Ottawa has been reviewing its decision to procure 88 F-35s to replace its ageing fighters and is considering a mixed fleet that will compound existing personnel shortfalls." Canada is increasingly looking to European manufacturers for its military buildup. Context: Relations between the two countries soured when Trump scrapped a free-trade agreement he insisted on in his first term, began a tariff war and threatened to annex Canada as the 51st state. At a Friday news conference, Trump complained about Canada and trade imbalances between the two countries. The bottom line: The two nations remain allies and work closely together on defense issues. Canada has an office in the Pentagon next to the joint staff. The limited restrictions imposed by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth on official interactions between U.S. and Canadian personnel are a "shot across the bow," a U.S. official said. "Unfortunately," the Pentagon fact sheet said, "Canada has yet to make the hard decisions and tradeoffs needed to put it on track to fulfill its NATO Defense Investment Pledge and become a credible partner in the