The Atlantic
The Relationship That Can Survive Not Talking for Years
Something unusual happens when friends reconnect.
If you don’t speak with a relative for years, you’re probably estranged. If you’re dating someone who’s dropped contact for the past month, you’ve been ghosted. You haven’t heard from your boss in six months? Uh-oh. But one kind of relationship seems to consistently defy the laws of interpersonal physics: friendship. When friends reunite, the fabric of time can pleat seamlessly, allowing them to simply, as the saying goes, pick up where they left off.
“Time doesn’t take away from true friendship, nor does separation,” Tennessee Williams wrote in Memoirs. “When we’re together, the years fall away,” Judy Blume once wrote of her best friend, Mary. In the 100 interviews with groups of friends that I conducted for my series The Friendship Files, I often heard similar sentiments. “It was like we’d never been apart,” one person told me of reconnecting with his Army buddies after more than a decade. “It’s as if nothing has changed,” another said of their relationship with friends from kindergarten.
If friendship has a superpower, it is the time travel of reconnection. Before these moments, sometimes weeks, months, or years pass with only sporadic communication, if not complete silence. Yet through these fallow periods, friendship can persist without diminishing in strength.
I’ve come to think of these empty spaces as friendship’s dark matter. It is the part of friendship we can’t see, directly measure, or definitively prove exists—but we know it’s there, and we feel its effects. In a 1991 paper, Stuart Sigman, a communication researcher, emphasized the importance of the part of relationships that happens in the silence between interactions. “Relationships do not cease after the face-to-face events (conversations) engaged in by co-members are terminated,” he wrote. “In a sense, relationships are ‘larger’ than the physical presence or interactional accessibility of the participants.”
Although all relationships have some of this dark matter, friendship is unusual because of how much silence it can survive. Someone doesn’t necessarily lose the title of “friend” just because you haven’t talked to them in a while. With family or romantic partners, a reunion after a long separation could be expected to bring some drama. Yet seeing an old friend is often described as frictionless.
[Read: How friendships change in adulthood]
The nature of friendship allows for this goodwill. “Freedom lives at the heart of friendship,” William Rawlins, an emeritus professor of communication at Ohio University, told me. You can’t choose your parents, but every friendship is created from scratch by the participants themselves. It can take any form they imagine. Cultures have shared expectations for how romantic relationships progress and when families ought to gather. Although couples and families don’t necessarily conform to those scripts, they’re still aware of them.
Those cultural guideposts barely exist for friendship. There is no universal prescription for how often friends ought to talk to or see one another. “Our friendship is going to exist as long as we are living up to each other’s expectations of the friendship,” Rawlins said. Friendships can go dormant for a while without dying, he wrote in his 1992 book, Friendship Matters, so long as all parties still think of one another as friends: “The unspoken in friendship, its shared image, may excuse former neglect.”
So what is happening when nothing is happening between friends? This is the question Kinneret Lahad, a professor of women’s studies at Tel Aviv University, explored in a paper she published last year. The short answer, as she wrote, is that when nothing happens, “everything happens at the same time.” The full answer is more complicated.
“Friendship is imbued with so many sensations, so many intensities that cannot be quantified or qualified or represented in narratives,” Lahad told me. (I’ll try my best to represent some of them in this narrative nevertheless.) Nothing visible or measurable may be happening between two friends; they may be, by all appearances, out of touch. But perhaps they think of each other often. Maybe one helped the other find a job that took them to a new place many years ago; their whole life trajectory remains shaped by that friendship, even though they’re now apart. One friend might see something that makes them think of the other, wonder whether they should reach out, and almost do it, only to hesitate at the last moment. Any or all of that could be happening when a friendship appears dormant. “When nothing is happening in friendship, all of friendship’s ambiguities, possibilities, and constraints are laid bare,” Rawlins said. Lahad’s point is that all of these almosts, maybes, and intangible thoughts still matter. They still affect the friendship and the people within it. This dark matter can, like the universe’s, be the glue that keeps friends together, or it can be the shadows in which misunderstandings and resentments fester.
One indirect piece of evidence for the existence of friendship dark matter is that the feeling of closeness between friends is not necessarily linked to how often they are in touch. In a study of long-distance and geographically close friends, Amy Janan Johnson, a professor of communication at the University of Oklahoma, found that although far-flung friends did fewer “maintenance behaviors”—such as calling each other, joking around together, and offering emotional support—that did not mean they felt less connected or invested in the relationship.
In fact, she told me, some long-distance friends’ commitment to the relationship was “still increasing.” Johnson suggested that in addition to the active maintenance of talking to and seeing one another, people might also engage in passive maintenance of their friendships by, for instance, looking at old photos and feeling fond feelings, or thinking of someone and wishing them well. These things seem small and ephemeral, but they are ways that friendship can be present even in absence. And they may contribute to the feeling, upon reunion, that the friendship was never interrupted at all.
[Read: Want closer friendships? Move away from your friends.]
Lahad recently published another paper, with her friend and co-author Klara Goedecke, about the feeling of reconnecting after a period of nothingness. And in the most scholarly way possible, they basically said that it’s magic: “Sensed suspension of the sociotemporal order that would otherwise cast time apart as rupture has a ‘mythical’ or ‘extra-temporal’ quality,” they wrote, “which we conceptualize as a sense of wonder.”
This wonder is not guaranteed. Let us not over-romanticize the flexibility of friendship; it is completely possible that the dark matter contains not the comforting certainty of continued connection, but confusion and hurt. Friends can drift apart over long separations, and reuniting may be awkward rather than smooth. “Meeting up with an old friend constituted a friendship trial,” Lahad and Goedecke wrote, “a moment where the friendship was put to the test, as it were.” Reconnection comes with risk. Although you may have thought that everything was fine, that it was mutually understood that you still loved each other through the silence, your friend might be upset with you for not reaching out. “Treasured old friendships persist partly as vital (and hopefully mutual) fantasies,” Rawlins wrote. The risk is that the fantasy is not mutual.
As technology has made keeping in touch easier and easier, the dark matter of friendship may feel heavier than it did in previous generations. Rawlins and Johnson both pointed out that for those who didn’t grow up with the internet and social media, and had only calls and letters to bridge the distance, long silences between friends may have felt more benign. Friends have so many ways to reach out to one another now that it may feel more fraught when they don’t.
This sense that reconnection is risky could be why, as a couple of studies have found, people tend to be reluctant to contact their old friends. Even when they say they’d like to, many hesitate to actually do it. But the risk may not be as high as they think. Another study found that people tend to consistently underestimate how happy those in their social circle are to hear from them.
What makes a friendship more or less likely to pick up where it left off? Kristina Castaneto, a psychology Ph.D. student at Simon Fraser University, in Canada, is trying to investigate what makes a person more likely to reconnect with an old friend; her adviser, Lara Aknin, worked on the study about reluctance to reach out. In a recent study, they could not find any personality traits that were linked to someone’s likelihood of getting back in touch. The only thing that seemed to move the needle was a new concept they’ve come up with: friendship resiliency, which they define as “the belief that the friendship will remain despite how much time has passed,” Castaneto told me. That sounds, essentially, like a belief in friendship dark matter. She is still working on developing a way to reliably measure this concept. But it seems possible that the very thing that brings friends back together might be the belief that they’re never truly separated, even when they’re apart.
Yet I can’t help but wonder how much this phenomenon is a special property of friendship, and how much it is a survival mechanism in a culture that puts friendship last. Lahad said that she and Goedecke got a similar critique from a colleague regarding their paper on reconnection and wonder. People should be working on their friendships, this person said, not coasting on the assumption that the time apart will collapse when they get back together. The dominant values of American culture—and many other cultures—still say that you should prioritize your work and your family before your friends. When friendship is expected to make way for these other things, people may get used to tolerating lapses in contact, or think that they have no choice but to accept them as part of friendship.
The “assumption of benevolence” through a dormant period, as Rawlins put it, can be a beautiful part of friendship. But “at the same time, Julie, at some point, you kind of have to live that with each other,” he told me. You have to prove the benevolent assumption correct. You have to actually pick up where you left off. That’s the thing about friendship dark matter—it can hold the visible matter together … so long as there is some visible matter.
Friendship does require taking action, at some point, if you want it to be more than a fond memory. But it is more than the sum of the actions taken. Even if you do make your friends a priority, even if you are regularly in touch, the magic, unmeasurable dark matter remains. Lahad told me about a woman she’d interviewed whose friend had offered her a room to stay in when she was thinking of divorcing her husband. She never took her friend up on it, but just knowing that she had that safety net if she needed it helped give her the confidence to take action and get divorced. Something that wasn’t actually happening was shaping everything. “Friendship also exists in these ways that cannot be boiled down only to how often we meet and how often we talk,” Lahad said.
In the dark matter, there is uncertainty, yes. But, as Rawlins said, “the other side of uncertainty is faith.”